Top Frozen Pizza
Based on community reviews & Amazon ratings
1
Red Baron Frozen Pizza
94%
1%
great value; classic crust; reliable quality; nostalgic taste
2
Home Run Inn Frozen Pizza
93%
2%
buttery crust; high-quality cheese; tavern style; divisive texture
3
Motor City Pizza Co.
92%
3%
thick detroit-style; crispy edges; buttery crust; double pepperoni recommended
4
Screamin' Sicilian Frozen Pizza
90%
5%
generous toppings; thick crust; premium ingredients; fun packaging
5
Totino's Party Frozen Pizza
88%
7%
nostalgic; cheap; cracker crust; guilty pleasure
6
Lotzza Motzza Frozen Pizza
87%
8%
cheese-heavy; tavern style; midwest favorite; rich toppings
7
Freschetta Frozen Pizza
85%
10%
rising crust; reliable; naturally rising; quality sauce
8
Newman's Own Pizza Frozen
84%
11%
thin crust; charity-based; high quality; stone-fired
9
Dogtown Frozen Pizza
83%
12%
St. Louis style; cracker crust; creamy cheese; regional favorite
10
Heggies Frozen Pizza
81%
14%
Midwest cult classic; high quality toppings; best in pizza oven; expensive