← Eyeliner
Stila Stay All Day Liquid Eye Liner

Stila Stay All Day Liquid Eye Liner

waterproof formula withstands tears; felt tip for easy application; cult classic reputation; frequent complaints of drying out quickly

Aggregated Pros
  • Waterproof formula withstands tears
  • Felt tip for easy application
  • Cult classic reputation
Aggregated Cons
  • Frequent complaints of drying out quickly

Reddit Reviews:


Positive
Reddit Icon
u/redditor · r/AsianBeauty

“Stila stay all day liquid eye liner is the best. I have very oily skin and this works for me. Doesn't smudge at all. For bottom lid, I use ...”

r/AsianBeauty · [Discussion] What's a good eyeliner for monolid eyes that ..… →
Positive
Reddit Icon
u/redditor · r/MakeupAddiction

“Best: Stila Smudge Stick eyeliner. Glides on without tugging and amazing color range.”

r/MakeupAddiction · Thread: Best/Worst of Stila : r/MakeupAddiction →
Neutral
Reddit Icon
u/redditor · r/Sephora

“I recently got the stila eyeliner bc I was in a dire need of an eyeliner after my nyx one dried out and I wanted to get a good eyeliner and stila was on ...”

r/Sephora · Thoughts on the stila eyeliner? : r/Sephora →
Negative
Reddit Icon
u/redditor · r/MakeupAddictionCanada

“The one I use is Precision Liquid Eyeliner, which has a brush applicator, opposed to a felt tip (which I don't prefer.) It ...”

r/MakeupAddictionCanada · Alternative to Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Line… →
Neutral
Reddit Icon
u/redditor · r/MakeupAddiction

“i've been using stila stay all day for ages, but it's getting unsustainable for how expensive it is. i do really thick eyeliner and it's ...”

r/MakeupAddiction · i've been using stila stay all day for ages, but it's gettin… →
Negative
Reddit Icon
u/redditor · r/MakeupAddiction

“I've been using Stila eyeliner for years and my last two are awful. It usually lasts 6 months before drying out and starts out gliding well and pigmented. ...”

r/MakeupAddiction · Did the Stila Stay All Day Eyeliner Formula Change? →
View more on Reddit →